The Newest Testament - Cast

Name	Known for
Luke Barnett Jesus Jesus See fewer	For All Mankind (2019)
Katie Featherston Deborah Deborah See fewer	Paranormal Activity (2007)
Carly Craig Sue Sue See fewer	Role Models (2008)
Richard Riehle Stephen Stephen See fewer	The Man from Earth (2007)
Ashlynn Yennie Rachel Rachel See fewer	Hidden Intentions (2018)
Marlon Young Tom Tom See fewer	War of the Worlds (2005)
Lisa Schwartz Mary Mary See fewer	Party Girl (2016)
Caroline Macey Rebecca Rebecca See fewer	Grey's Anatomy (2005)
Tanner Thomason John John See fewer	Faith Based (2020)
Alexis Boyett Cocktail Waitress Cocktail Waitress See fewer	Adrenochrome (2017)
Ana Harrison Bartender Bartender See fewer	Amber Road (2022)
Danny Herb Bro #1 Bro #1 See fewer	Lishy Lou and Lucky Too (2013)
Cheik Letang Black Jesus Black Jesus See fewer	Fear, Inc. (2016)
Jeremiah Lowder Sauna Man Sauna Man See fewer	Wasted (2006)
Zach Pope Bro #2 Bro #2 See fewer	Lost Gold (2017)
Melissa Rosen Promiscuous Woman Promiscuous Woman See fewer	Credit Cards vs. Debit Cards: Know Your Rights (2012)
David Ury James James See fewer	Better Call Saul (2015)