The Not Too Late Show with Elmo - Cast

Name	Episodes	Known for
Ryan Dillon Elmo - Host / Elmo Elmo - Host / Elmo See fewer	14	Sesame Street (1969)
David Rudman Cookie Monster / Cookie Monster - Co-Host Cookie Monster / Cookie Monster - Co-Host See fewer	13	The Muppets (2011)
Samantha McDanel Actress Actress See fewer	13	The Happytime Murders (2018)
Stephanie D'Abruzzo Mae - Elmo's Mom Mae - Elmo's Mom See fewer	10	Scrubs (2001)
Tyler Bunch Louie - Elmo's Dad Louie - Elmo's Dad See fewer	10	Sesame Street (1969)
Jennifer Barnhart Mama Bear / Zoe Mama Bear / Zoe See fewer	9	Between the Lions (1999)
Joey Curtis-Green Audience Audience See fewer	8	Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999)
Carmen Osbahr Rosita Rosita See fewer	7	The Puzzle Place (1994)
Eric Jacobson Grover / Oscar the Grouch / Bert Grover / Oscar the Grouch / Bert See fewer	6	The Muppets (2011)
Peter Linz Ernie / Herry Monster Ernie / Herry Monster See fewer	4	The Muppets (2011)
John Oliver Self - Special Guest / Self - Guest Self - Special Guest / Self - Guest See fewer	3	Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (2014)
Matt Vogel Big Bird / Mr. Johnson / The Count Big Bird / Mr. Johnson / The Count See fewer	3	Sesame Street (1969)
Leslie Carrara-Rudolph Abby Cadabby / Interrupting Cow Abby Cadabby / Interrupting Cow See fewer	3	Sesame Street (1969)
Blake Lively Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Gossip Girl (2007)
Olivia Wilde Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Don't Worry Darling (I) (2022)
Jason Sudeikis Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Ted Lasso (2020)
John Mulaney Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018)
Jimmy Fallon Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (2014)
Pentatonix Themselves - Musical Guest Themselves - Musical Guest See fewer	1	The Grinch (2018)
Miles Brown Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Black-ish (2014)
Mykal-Michelle Harris Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Cheaper by the Dozen (2022)
Hoda Kotb Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Marry Me (2022)
Andy Cohen Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	The N Word (2004)
Jonas Brothers Themselves - Guests Themselves - Guests See fewer	1	Aquamarine (2006)
Nicholas A. Jacinto Self - Special Guest Self - Special Guest See fewer	1	The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (2017)
Josh Groban Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Troy (2004)
Ben Platt Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Pitch Perfect (2012)
Jordin Sparks Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Sparkle (I) (2012)
Sara Bareilles Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Little Voice (2020)
Jonathan Van Ness Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Queer Eye (2018)
Ciara Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	That's My Boy (2012)
Kacey Musgraves Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Live by Night (2016)
Lil Nas X Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Lil Nas X: Montero (Call Me by Your Name) (2021)
Dan + Shay Themselves - Musical Guest Themselves - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Dan + Shay: Tequila (2018)
Kwame Alexander Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	The Crossover (2023)
Joyous String Ensemble Themselves - Musical Guest Themselves - Musical Guest See fewer	1	The Not Too Late Show with Elmo (2020)
Sofia Carson Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Purple Hearts (2022)
H.E.R. Self - Musical Guest Self - Musical Guest See fewer	1	Judas and the Black Messiah (2021)
Alan Muraoka Alan Alan See fewer	1	It Could Happen to You (1994)
Martin P. Robinson Telly Monster Telly Monster See fewer	1	Sesame Street (1969)
Victor Joel Ortiz Batman Batman See fewer	1	Tommy (2020)
John Kennedy Actor Actor See fewer	1	Old Dogs (I) (2009)
Pam Arciero Actress Actress See fewer	1	Sesame Street (1969)
Frankie Cordero Actor Actor See fewer	1	Donkey Hodie (2021)
Mona Tavakoli Self - Sara's Bandmate Self - Sara's Bandmate See fewer	1	Black or White (2014)
Chaska Potter Self - Sara's Bandmate Self - Sara's Bandmate See fewer	1	Black or White (2014)
Ziva Jane Self Self See fewer	1	ElemenTory (2024)
Donovan Monzon-Sanders Self Self See fewer	1	Blue Bloods (2010)
Felice Kakaletris Felice 2021 Felice 2021 See fewer	1	Annie Live! (2021)
Skylar Clifford Skylar Clifford Skylar Clifford See fewer	1	Evil Lives Here (2016)
Tamron Hall Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Tamron Hall (2019)
AJR Performers / Themselves- Musical Guests Performers / Themselves- Musical Guests See fewer	1	Jexi (2019)
Ryan Met Ryan Met Ryan Met See fewer	1	Jexi (2019)
Jayla Lavender Nicholas Self Self See fewer	1	Karma's World (2021)
Brandon Niederauer Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Saturday Night (2024)
Lucia Diaz Self Self See fewer	1	Simchas and Sorrows (2022)
Darby Schlosser Contestant Contestant See fewer	1	Glass (2019)
Kelvin Dukes Restaurant Diner (Self) Restaurant Diner (Self) See fewer	1	The Other Two (2019)
Chase Merriweather Self - Guest Self - Guest See fewer	1	Tamron Hall (2019)