User talk:Lwalt/Coaching

Additional Questions from Dfrg.msc:

Borrowed from Glen (talk · contribs), I'm sure he wont mind. These should test you editing skills, and show if you have any weaknesses which you can work on. So, just write your answer next to the Question. Good luck.

OK...here are the best answers that I can come up with at the moment. →Lwalt ^♦ talk 22:14, 6 July 2007 (UTC)Reply

Speedy Delete or not:

1. CSD1 - Speedy delete based on CSD #1 and CSD #7 for articles, esp. since person is a member of a non-notable band and article consists of of only one line. As for "Dan Morrow," a notable person by this name is referenced here, but this does not appear to the same person who in this band.
2. CSD2 - Speedy delete based on CSD #11 under general criteria (promotional; advertising).
3. CSD3 - Should be prodded instead of speedy deleted in its current form. Need more general information and references (references use of service for public interviews and consumer research) to fill out article without promotional advertising. Are you referring to this company?
4. CSD4 - Speedy delete based on CSD #1 under general criteria.
5. CSD5 - Speedy delete based on CSD # 7 for articles (non-notable). Also, no information can be found that suggests that band has charted on major music chart.

Vandalism or or not:

1. [1] - Vandalism. No information can be found to suggest that "Maggie Stapleton is widely regarded as the greatest American Pokemon champion," as shown in this search.
2. [2] - Vandalism. Besides, what does the mathematical equation has to do with Pokemon as a game and cultural phenomenon?
3. [3] - Definitely vandalism. The Courier-Mail is a news publication, so Ya Mum (which is the same as uttering Yo Mamma in the US slang lexicon) has no place in this article.
4. [4] - Vandalism. The "garbage" heading gives this edit away.
5. [5] - Not vandalism. The references "1 generation" is OK (don't know why the editor decided to change this from "First Generation," unless the person was using jargon commonly referred to in this instance), used in the same way as found here.
6. [6] - Vandalism? Here's my best guess - Sunkern, a Type 1 grass character in the seed species, is a member of the plant breeding group that only fares well against other characters in its own group.