John Anderson (philosopher)

Anderson was born in Stonehouse, Lanarkshire, Scotland and educated at the former Hamilton Academy from which school he won a bursary to attend the University of Glasgow in the university's Bursary Competition of 1911.^[2][3] Anderson was listed among notable former pupils of Hamilton Academy in a 1950 magazine article on the school.^[4] His elder brother was William Anderson, Professor of Philosophy at Auckland University College, 1921 to his death in 1955, and described as "the most dominant figure in New Zealand philosophy."^[5]

Anderson graduated MA from Glasgow University in 1917, with first-class honours in Philosophy (Logic and Moral Philosophy), and first-class honours in Mathematics and Natural Philosophy. After graduation, he was awarded the Ferguson Scholarship in Philosophy and the Shaw Philosophical Fellowship, the examinations for which were open to graduates of any of the four Scottish universities.^[6]

He served as Assistant in Philosophy at the University College, Cardiff (Cardiff) (1917–19), in Moral Philosophy and Logic in the University of Glasgow (1919–20) and lectured in Logic and Metaphysics at the University of Edinburgh (1920–26).^[6]

After arriving in Sydney in 1927 he associated with the Communist Party of Australia and contributed to their journals, sometimes under a nom de plume^[2] but, by about 1932 he began to believe that communism under Joseph Stalin in the Soviet Union was a dictatorship with no room for workers' control or participation. He then became aligned with the Trotskyist movement for a period of time. But "[h]e could not put up any longer with dialectical materialism or with the servile state which he saw was being imposed by the doctrine of the dictatorship of the proletariat".^[2][7]

During the war years, Anderson developed a unique theory of liberal democracy where liberty was not a right, but an activity exercised in opposition to the State. Similarly, democracy was not a set of formal features of a system of government, but is the way a group proceeds in its decision making processes.^[8] After the war, he was vehemently opposed to Communism, describing it as 'the disease of the modern time'. He became what would today be called a libertarian and pluralist—an opponent of all forms of authoritarianism.

As Sydney University's Challis Professor of Philosophy, Anderson was a formidable champion of the principle of academic freedom from authoritarian intervention. For example, he fought a successful battle to end the role of the British Medical Association in setting course standards and student quotas in the medical school. He also railed against the presence on campus of a military unit—the Sydney University Regiment—and lived to see the day in 1960 when the regiment's campus HQ was destroyed by fire. (The regiment was subsequently rehoused at a new facility on university-owned land at Darlington.)^[9]

Anderson was censured by the Sydney University Senate in 1931 after criticising the role of war memorials in sanctifying war.^[10][11] In 1943 he was censured by the Parliament of New South Wales after arguing that religion has no place in schools. He founded the Sydney University Freethought Society^[12] which ran from 1931 to 1951. He was president of the society throughout that period.

It is legendary that the university's Senate, accepting that it could not realise its desire to sack the controversial Challis Professor, sought to reduce Anderson's stature and influence by creating a new chair of "Moral and Political Philosophy" to which Alan Stout was appointed.^[13] This purpose was not achieved, as Anderson continued to lecture on ethics and politics. Stout (who had been urged by Anderson to apply for the position) was a steady admirer and supporter of the Challis Professor and declined to undercut his prestige in any way. The result was that Sydney gained a second prestigious and personable philosopher who "brought a quick intelligence, intellectual grasp, a flair for putting things simply and clearly, together with a genuine respect for the views of others and readiness to appreciate their point of view". On Anderson's retirement, the two departments were merged under Stout as 'the Professor of Philosophy'.^[13]

During the thirties, Anderson was widely known as a systematic Realist. His Realism stressed the independence of a thing and its qualities from the relations around them. Hence, an object is not constituted by the perception of it, the truth of a proposition is not determined by the context that surrounds it, the goodness of an action is not determined by the relations that it has, and the beauty of a things is not determined by its relations. However this Realism was part of a wider ontological project known as Empiricism. This ontology was based on the view that the unity of Space and Time, Space-Time, was infinite and was only delimited by the specification of a particular portion of Space-Time, known as a situation. A 'thing' is an occurrence in Space-Time and has certain categorial features. These include identity, diversity, existence, relation, universality, particularity, number, order, quantity, intensity, substance, causality, and individuality. Any possible situation could be expressed in terms of a proposition, understood as the assertion of a subject term, a predicate term, a copula, and a quantifier. This is the core of Anderson's famous identity theory of the proposition: any situation can be expressed as a proposition and any proposition must be asserted in terms of a situation. Hence, situations and propositions are identical.^[14] As a committed empiricist, Anderson argued that there is only one realm of "being" and it can be best understood through science and naturalistic philosophy. He asserted that there is no supernatural god and that there are no non-natural realms along the lines of Platonic ideals.

Anderson had a wide influence on several generations of students at Sydney University.

He is, arguably, the most important philosopher who has worked in Australia. Certainly he was the most important in both the breadth and depth of influence. Among the philosophers who got their original intellectual formation from Anderson are John Passmore, John Mackie, A.J. ('Jim') Baker, David Stove and myself. There are lots more. But for every student who became a philosopher there were far, far, more in the law, in medicine, in journalism, in other academic disciplines, that were profoundly influenced by him. I am inclined to think that, especially in the thirties and forties of the last century, Anderson was the person who set the agenda, and set the tone, for intellectual discussion in Sydney.^[15] – David Armstrong (2005)

Anderson's influence has spread through his personal impact on several generations of students, the "Andersonians", who include the philosophers named above, together with Hedley Bull and Eugene Kamenka; the World War II organiser Alf Conlon, many members of the Sydney Push, Tonga's 'I. Futa Helu, and jurist John Kerr, later to be Australia's best-remembered governor-general. The Anglo-Australian political scientist Kenneth Minogue also cited Anderson as a major influence.

Anderson's insistence on unceasing inquiry and criticism became central to the intellectual principles of the university's Libertarian Society which supplanted the Freethought Society in the early 1950s and provided a philosophic platform for the much broader subculture known as "the Push" throughout the 1960s. He was a defender of free speech and was critical of the Australian government's bans on certain political publications (1928). He advocated religious and sexual freedoms and free discussion of issues in an era when mention of taboo subjects commonly resulted in angry public condemnation by prominent moralists.

After the Second World War, however, Anderson began exhibiting more conservative views. Jim Baker interprets this latter stage not so much as "a definite change in his overall thinking than ... an alteration of emphasis and interest".^[16]: p130 In other words, according to Baker, while Anderson's political positions changed over time his philosophy remained constant. To many, however, it seemed that Anderson was departing from his pluralism. During the 1949 coal miners' strike, for instance, he supported the government's action in using troops as strikebreakers.^[16] At a Freethought Society meeting in August 1950 he refused to oppose conscription for the war in Korea.^[17]: p12 In 1951 he refused to allow students to use the Freethought Society to canvass the 'No' case for Menzies' attempt to ban the Communist Party in the referendum of that year.^[17]: p130 This was the last straw for many Freethinkers; Anderson's apparent authoritarianism caused most to abandon the Freethought Society and to establish the Libertarian Society. (It must be pointed out that Anderson did not support the banning of the Communist Party—in fact he attacked the proposal.^[18]: p18) The Freethought Society held its last meeting in 1951.^[16]: p130 The Libertarian Society functioned from 1952 to 1969.^[16]: p144

Anderson broke off contact with the former disciples who formed the Libertarian Society and never associated with "Push" people who routinely sang his praises along with the bawdy songs he had imported to his new country.^[19] However, even after retirement in 1958 and to the brink of his death in 1962, he was seen daily in his study, continuing his work and reviewing earlier work. Among his last publications were Classicism (1960), Empiricism and Logic (1962) and Relational Arguments (1962).^[20]

• J. Anderson (Introduction by D. Armstrong), Space, Time and the Categories: Lectures on Metaphysics 1949–50 (Sydney University Press, 2007) (ISBN 978-1-920898-62-5) Details.
• J. Anderson, Regular contributions to The Australasian Journal of Psychology and Philosophy
• J. Anderson, Studies in Empirical Philosophy (Sydney: Angus and Robertson, 1962) [1] (ISBN 1-920898-17-4)
• J. Anderson, Religion in Education in "Religion in Education – Five Addresses Delivered Before the New Education Fellowship (N.S.W.)". The New Education Fellowship, Sydney, 1943 ISBN 0724060014
• Packer, James G. A Life of Thinking--The Andersonian Tradition in Australian Philosophy: a chronological bibliography

• Anderson, Janet; Cullum Graham; Lycos, Kimon (eds.). Art and Reality: John Anderson on Literature and Aesthetics (Sydney: Hale and Iremonger, 1982) ISBN 978-1743325094
• Baker A.J. Anderson's Social Philosophy: The Social Thought and Political Life of Professor John Anderson (Sydney: Angus & Robertson, 1979) ISBN 978-0207142161
• Baker, A.J. Australian Realism: The Systematic Philosophy of John Anderson (Cambridge University Press, 1986) ISBN 9780521320511
• Barcan A. Radical Students: The Old Left at Sydney University (Carlton South, Vic.: Melbourne University Press, 2002) review ISSN 0023-6942
• Creagh, Cole. A difficult legacy in Sydney Alumni Magazine (SAM), Winter 2009, p. 34 (fol.32)
• Franklin J., Corrupting the Youth: A History of Philosophy in Australia (Macleay Press, 2003), chs 1–2 ISBN 1876492082
• Kennedy B. A Passion to Oppose: John Anderson, Philosopher (Carlton South, Vic.: Melbourne University Press, 1995) ISBN 978-0522846836
• Weblin, Mark (ed.), A Perilous and Fighting Life: From Communist to Conservative: The Political Writings of Professor John Anderson (North Melbourne: Pluto Press, 2003) ISBN 9781864032482

 

Scholia has a profile for John Anderson (Q3296918).

• John Anderson Archive, University of Sydney
• John Anderson Studies in Empirical Philosophy Sydney University Press, 1962
• Professor John Anderson 1893–1962, Lecture Notes and Other Writings University of Sydney, Australian Studies Resources
• ABC Radio National transcript Philosopher's Zone, 8 September 2007
• ABC Radio National transcript Philosopher's Zone, 1 November 2008
• ABC Radio National audio Late Night Live, originally 19 February 2004
• Clive James on John Anderson (The Monthly, July 2005)
• W. M. O'Neil. Anderson, John (1893–1962). Biography at Australian Dictionary of Biography, 1979.