Pauling's principle of electroneutrality

Pauling's principle of electroneutrality states that each atom in a stable substance has a charge close to zero. It was formulated by Linus Pauling in 1948 and later revised.^[1] The principle has been used to predict which of a set of molecular resonance structures would be the most significant, to explain the stability of inorganic complexes and to explain the existence of π-bonding in compounds and polyatomic anions containing silicon, phosphorus or sulfur bonded to oxygen; it is still invoked in the context of coordination complexes.^[2]^[3] However, modern computational techniques indicate many stable compounds have a greater charge distribution than the principle predicts (they contain bonds with greater ionic character).^[4]

History

Pauling first stated his "postulate of the essential electroneutrality of atoms" in his 1948 Liversidge lecture (in a broad-ranging paper that also included his ideas on the calculation of oxidation states in molecules):

“...the electronic structure of substances is such as to cause each atom to have essentially zero resultant electrical charge, the amount of leeway being not greater than about +/- ½, and these resultant charges are possessed mainly by the most electropositive and electronegative atoms and are distributed in such a way as to correspond to electrostatic stability."^[5]

A slightly revised version was published in 1970:

“Stable molecules and crystals have electronic structures such that the electric charge of each atom is close to zero. Close to zero means between -1 and +1.”^[6]

Pauling said in his Liversidge lecture in 1948 that he had been led to the principle by a consideration of ionic bonding. In the gas phase, molecular caesium fluoride has a polar covalent bond. The large difference in electronegativity gives a calculated covalent character of 9%. In the crystal (CsF has the NaCl structure with both ions being 6-coordinate) if each bond has 9% covalent character the total covalency of Cs and F would be 54%. This would be represented by one bond of around 50% covalent character resonating between the six positions and the overall effect would be to reduce the charge on Cs to about + 0.5 and fluoride to -0.5. It seemed reasonable to him that since CsF is the most ionic of ionic compounds, most, if not all substances will have atoms with even smaller charges.^[5]

Applications of the principle

Explanation of the structure adopted by hydrogen cyanide

There are two possible structures for hydrogen cyanide, HCN and CNH, differing only as to the position of the hydrogen atom. The structure with hydrogen attached to nitrogen, CNH, leads to formal charges of -1 on carbon and +1 on nitrogen, which would be partially compensated for by the electronegativity of nitrogen and Pauling calculated the net charges on H, N and C as -0.79, +0.75 and +0.04 respectively. In contrast the structure with hydrogen bonded to carbon, HCN, has formal charges on carbon and nitrogen of 0, and the effect of the electronegativity of the nitrogen would make the charges on H, C and N +0.04, +0.17 and -0.21.^[6] The triple bonded structure is therefore favored.

Relative contribution of resonance structures (canonicals)

As an example the cyanate ion (OCN)⁻ can be assigned three resonance structures:-

{\ce {^{-}O-C{\equiv }N<->O=C=N^{-}<->{^{+}O{\equiv }C-N^{2-}}}}

The rightmost structure in the diagram has a charge of -2 on the nitrogen atom. Applying the principle of electroneutrality this can be identified as only a minor contributor. Additionally as the most electronegative atom should carry the negative charge, then the triple bonded structure on the left is predicted to be the major contributor.^[7]

Stability of complexes

The hexammine cobalt(III) complex [Co(NH₃)₆]³⁺ would have all of charge on the central Co atom if the bonding to the ammonia molecules were electrostatic. On the other hand, a covalent linkage would lead to a charge of -3 on the metal and +1 on each of the nitrogen atoms in the ammonia molecules. Using the electroneutrality principle the assumption is made that the Co-N bond will have 50% ionic character thus resulting in a zero charge on the cobalt atom. Due to the difference in electronegativity the N-H bond would 17% ionic character and therefore a charge of 0.166 on each of the 18 hydrogen atoms. This essentially spreads the 3+ charge evenly onto the "surface" of the complex ion.^[1]

π-bonding in oxo compounds of Si, P, and S

Pauling invoked the principle of electroneutrality in a 1952 paper to suggest that pi bonding is present, for example, in molecules with 4 Si-O bonds.^[8] The oxygen atoms in such molecules would form polar covalent bonds with the silicon atom because their electronegativity (electron withdrawing power) was higher than that of silicon. Pauling calculated the charge build up on the silicon atom due to the difference in electronegativity to be +2. The electroneutrality principle led Pauling to the conclusion that charge transfer from O to Si must occur using d orbitals forming a π-bond and he calculated that this π-bonding accounted for the shortening of the Si-O bond.

The adjacent charge rule

The "adjacent charge rule" was another principle of Pauling's for determining whether a resonance structure would make a significant contribution.^[1] First published in 1932, it stated that structures that placed charges of the same sign on adjacent atoms would be unfavorable.^[9]^[10]

References

^ ^a ^b ^c The Nature of the Chemical bond, L. Pauling, 1960, 3d edition, pp. 172-173, 270, 273, 547 Cornell University Press, ISBN 0-8014-0333-2
^ Housecroft, C. E.; Sharpe, A. G. (2004). Inorganic Chemistry (2nd ed.). Prentice Hall. ISBN 978-0-13-039913-7.
^ R.H. Crabtree, The Organometallic Chemistry of the Transition Metals, 6th edition, John Wiley & Sons, (e-book), ISBN 9781118788240
^ Kaupp, Martin (January 1, 2001). "Chapter 1: Chemical bonding of main group elements". In Frenking, Gernot; Shaik, Sason (eds.). The Chemical Bond: Chemical Bonding Across the Periodic Table. Wiley -VCH. pp. 15–16. ISBN 978-3-527-33315-8.
^ ^a ^b Pauling, Linus (1948). "The modern theory of valency". Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed). 17: 1461–1467. doi:10.1039/jr9480001461. ISSN 0368-1769. PMID 18893624.
^ ^a ^b General Chemistry, Linus Pauling, 1988 p 192, Dover (reprint of 3d edition orig. pub. W.H. Freeman 1970), ISBN 0-486-65622-5
^ John Kotz, Paul Treichel, John Townsend, David Treichel, 7th Edition, 2009, Chemistry & Chemical Reactivity, pp. 378-379, Thomson Brooks/Cole, ISBN 978-0495387039
^ Pauling, Linus (1952). "Interatomic Distances and Bond Character in the Oxygen Acids and Related Substances". The Journal of Physical Chemistry. 56 (3): 361–365. doi:10.1021/j150495a016. ISSN 0022-3654.
^ L Pauling, The Electronic Structure of the Normal Nitrous Oxide Molecule, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1932, 18, 498
^ Pauling, Linus; Brockway, L. O. (1937). "The Adjacent Charge Rule and the Structure of Methyl Azide, Methyl Nitrate, and Fluorine Nitrate". Journal of the American Chemical Society. 59 (1): 13–20. doi:10.1021/ja01280a005. ISSN 0002-7863.

[Pauling_Nature_Chemical_bond-1] The Nature of the Chemical bond, L. Pauling, 1960, 3d edition, pp. 172-173, 270, 273, 547 Cornell University Press, ISBN 0-8014-0333-2

[2] Housecroft, C. E.; Sharpe, A. G. (2004). Inorganic Chemistry (2nd ed.). Prentice Hall. ISBN 978-0-13-039913-7.

[3] R.H. Crabtree, The Organometallic Chemistry of the Transition Metals, 6th edition, John Wiley & Sons, (e-book), ISBN 9781118788240

[4] Kaupp, Martin (January 1, 2001). "Chapter 1: Chemical bonding of main group elements". In Frenking, Gernot; Shaik, Sason (eds.). The Chemical Bond: Chemical Bonding Across the Periodic Table. Wiley -VCH. pp. 15–16. ISBN 978-3-527-33315-8.

[Pauling1948-5] Pauling, Linus (1948). "The modern theory of valency". Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed). 17: 1461–1467. doi:10.1039/jr9480001461. ISSN 0368-1769. PMID 18893624.

[Pauling_GENCHEM-6] General Chemistry, Linus Pauling, 1988 p 192, Dover (reprint of 3d edition orig. pub. W.H. Freeman 1970), ISBN 0-486-65622-5

[7] John Kotz, Paul Treichel, John Townsend, David Treichel, 7th Edition, 2009, Chemistry & Chemical Reactivity, pp. 378-379, Thomson Brooks/Cole, ISBN 978-0495387039

[Pauling1952-8] Pauling, Linus (1952). "Interatomic Distances and Bond Character in the Oxygen Acids and Related Substances". The Journal of Physical Chemistry. 56 (3): 361–365. doi:10.1021/j150495a016. ISSN 0022-3654.

[9] L Pauling, The Electronic Structure of the Normal Nitrous Oxide Molecule, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1932, 18, 498

[PaulingBrockway1937-10] Pauling, Linus; Brockway, L. O. (1937). "The Adjacent Charge Rule and the Structure of Methyl Azide, Methyl Nitrate, and Fluorine Nitrate". Journal of the American Chemical Society. 59 (1): 13–20. doi:10.1021/ja01280a005. ISSN 0002-7863.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]