Trial of Alexander Bobikin and Alexander Ivanov
The trial of Alexander Bobikin and Alexander Ivanov was the second trial for war crimes in the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine,[1] through which two Russian soldiers were charged with "violating the laws and customs of war", under Part 1 of Article 438 of the Criminal code of Ukraine, in relation to a shelling that damaged an education facility on 24 February 2022, during the battle of Kharkiv. Bobikin and Ivanov were tried in a 90-minute session on 19 May 2022 and a 30-minute session on 26 May in Poltava.[2] They were sentenced on 31 May 2022 to eleven and a half years' imprisonment.[3][4][5]
Attack on Kharkiv Raion
[edit]The battle of Kharkiv took place from 24 February to mid-May 2022 during the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine.[6][7] Prior to the invasion, in December 2021, a Russian military unit including Alexander Bobikin and Alexander Ivanov was told that it would be involved in a training exercise. Around 1 February 2022, the unit went to Kursk for training. The unit was later moved to Malinovka in Belgorod Oblast, where the soldiers were told that they would enter Ukraine, for unexplained reasons.[2]
Bobikin and Ivanov participated in the attacks on 24 February, began shelling around 05:00 local time, and fired about 38 shells from their vehicle. According to Ivanov, some of the unit's members refused to fire the shells while still on Russian territory.[2]
The unit entered Ukraine and fired more shells, and was later dispersed by Ukrainian forces. Bobikin's vehicle was damaged, and he lost consciousness after being thrown out of it. Ivanov surrendered on 25 February and Bobikin surrendered ten days later. A YouTube interview with the two was published on 27 April, with Ivanov describing the procedures of firing BM-21 Grad shells.[2][3]
The shelling destroyed an "educational facility", without killing anyone.[5]
Court sessions
[edit]On 7 May 2022, the Prosecutor General of Ukraine announced that charges against Bobikin and Ivanov would be laid for "violating the laws and customs of war" under Part 1 of Article 438 of the Criminal code of Ukraine.[3][1]
On 17 May, Alexander Bobikin and Alexander Ivanov attended a pre-trial hearing, with Ukrainian legal defence and an interpreter. They chose trial by a single judge.[3]
On 19 May, Bobikin and Ivanov appeared in a 90-minute trial session in a court in Poltava,[3] accused of having been involved in shelling civilian facilities in Kharkiv Raion. Bobikin and Ivanov were accused of firing BM-21 Grad shells from Russian territory, in the village of Malinovka in Belgorod Oblast, at Kozacha Lopan and another village in Ukraine, on 24 February 2022.[2] Both pled guilty.[2][3]
On 26 May, a 30-minute session took place during which Bobikin, Ivanov, the defence and the prosecution presented their sentencing arguments.[3] The defence lawyers, Valeriya Ivanov and Uladzimir Kavalchuk, called for a reduced sentence of eight years on the grounds of genuine remorse and having acted under orders.[8]
On 31 May 2022, Bobikin and Ivanov were found guilty and sentenced to eleven and a half years of imprisonment, just below the maximum penalty of twelve years.[4][5] Judge Evhen Bolybok described the conviction as having "been proven in full".[1] Law professor Chris Jenks argued that Bobikin and Ivanov's surrender, cooperation, guilty plea and apologies should have led to a more lenient sentence.[3]
Intent to attack civilian targets
[edit]Bobikin and Ivanov stated that they did not know the targets that they shot shells at.[2] Law professor Chris Jenks argued that, as junior-ranked soldiers inserting numbers into their targeting equipment, it was unlikely that Bobikin and Ivanov would have been aware of whether their targets were lawful or not, and neither the publicly stated charges nor the media reports of the trial showed on what basis Bobikin and Ivanov could have knowingly "launched" an indiscriminate attack against civilian targets, with awareness of the likely consequences. He argued that mens rea, criminal intent, was missing from the case.[3] War crimes specialist Robert Goldman stated that establishing a war crime required proof that Bobikin and Ivanov had attacked civilian targets deliberately or had acted disproportionally, ignoring the likely civilian impact.[6]
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ a b c "Ukrainian court finds two Russian soldiers guilty of war crimes". Al Jazeera English. 2022-05-31. Archived from the original on 2022-06-17. Retrieved 2022-07-09.
- ^ a b c d e f g Ізотов, Ігор; Литвак, Дарина (2022-05-19). "У суді на Полтавщині розглядають справу щодо двох російських військових" [Poltava court considers case against two Russian servicemen]. Suspilne Media (in Ukrainian). Archived from the original on 2022-07-01. Retrieved 2022-07-08.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Jenks, Chris (2022-06-24). "Ukraine Symposium – The Atrocity Crimes Advisory Group & Ukrainian Prosecutions of Russian POWs – Part 2". Lieber Institute, West Point. Archived from the original on 2022-07-06. Retrieved 2022-07-08.
- ^ a b "Ukraine jails two Russian soldiers for shelling villages". The Guardian. 2022-05-31. Archived from the original on 2022-06-30. Retrieved 2022-07-09.
- ^ a b c Parker, Claire; Francis, Ellen; Chapman, Annabelle (2022-05-31). "Russian soldiers get prison terms in second Ukraine war crimes trial". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 2022-07-05. Retrieved 2022-07-09.
- ^ a b "Why Kharkiv, a city known for its poets, has become a key battleground in Ukraine". The Washington Post. 28 February 2022. Archived from the original on 8 July 2022. Retrieved 1 March 2022.
- ^ "Russian Offensive Campaign Assessment, May 3". Institute for the Study of War. 3 May 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-06-13. Retrieved 3 May 2022.
- ^ Sokolova, Hannah (2022-05-31). ""Не оспаривается обвиняемыми". Двух российских военных признали виновными в первом артиллерийской обстреле Харьковской области" ["Uncontested by the defendants". Two Russian soldiers found guilty in first artillery shelling in Kharkiv region]. Grati (in Ukrainian). Archived from the original on 2022-07-01. Retrieved 2022-07-09.
