Abstract
In this paper I address three problems posed by modern medical technology regarding comatose dying patients. The first is that physicians sometimes hide behind the tests for whole-brain death rather than make the necessary human decision. The second is that the tests themselves betray a metaphysical judgment about death that may be ontologically faulty. The third is that discretion used by physicians and patients and/or family in deciding to cease treatment when the whole-brain death criteria may not be met are sometimes open to challenge. In each of these problems I find that the operative concept of death relates to life itself. This point is expanded by examining the uses of the word ‘death’ in our language and culture. From these I formulate an initial ontology of death. In it, death is described through a relationship with life, rather than as an absence of life, of consciousness, awareness, or sensation. This ontology then leads to a proposal for an ethics of discretion about the discontinuation of treatment for comatose patients.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackerman, T.: 1980, ‘What bioethics should be’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 5, 260–275.
Alexander, M.: June 1980, ‘The rigid embrace of the narrow house: Premature burial and signs of death’, Hastings Center Report 10, 25.
April 26, 1982, ‘In coma since '79, Cop regains consciousness’, Chicago Tribune 1, 2.
Bernat, J. L., Culver, C. M., and Gert, B.: February 1982, ‘Defining death in theory and practice’, Hastings Center Report 12, 5.
Bryson, K.: 1974, ‘Being and human death’, The New Scholasticism 47, 343–350.
Byrne, P. A., O'Reilly, S., and Quay, P. M.: 1979, ‘Brain death — An opposing viewpoint’, Journal of American Medical Association 242, 1985–1990.
Camus, A.: 1963, Resistance, Rebellion, Death, Modern Library, New York, pp. 83–84.
Culver, C. M. and Gert, B.: 1982, Philosophy in Medicine: Conceptual and Ethical Issues in Medicine and Psychiatry, Oxford University Press, New York, p. 181.
Dubos, R.: 1972, God Within, Scribner, New York.
Edwards, P.: 1969, ‘Existentialism and death: A survey of some confusions and absurdities’, in S. Morgenbesser, P. Suppes and M. White (eds.) Philosophy, Science, and Method, St. Martin's Press, New York, pp. 484–503.
Jennett, B. and Plum, B.: 1972, ‘Persistent vegetative state after brain damage: A syndrome in search of a name’, Lancet 1, 734–737.
Jonsen, A., Seigler, M., and Winslade, W.: 1982, Clinical Ethics, Macmillan, New York.
Kass, L.: 1971, ‘Response to R. S. Morison’, Science 173, 698–702.
Kaufman, S.: 1975, Falling Bodies, Bantam Books, New York, pp. 215–247.
Larue, G. A.: 1975, Ancient Myth and Modern Man, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., pp. 151–182.
May, R.: 1969, Love and Will, Norton, New York, Chapter 2.
Morison, R. S.: 1971, ‘Death: Process or event?’, Science 173, 694–698.
Micetich, K., Steinecker, P., and Thomasma, D.: 1983, ‘Are IV fluids morally required for dying patients?’, Archives of Internal Medicine 143, 975–978.
Nov. 12, 1965, ‘On death as a constant companion’, Time 52–53.
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research: 1981, Defining Death: Medical, Legal, and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., p. 58.
Recommendation of the AMA Judicial Council: 1981, American Medical News 24.
Sept. 3, 1982, ‘M.D.'s charged with murder’, American Medical News 16.
Siirala, A.: 1974, ‘Dying as a rhythm in living’, The Ecumenist 55–60.
Silber, S.: 1974, ‘Death's other kingdom’, Resident and Staff Physician, 88–91.
Toulmin, S.: 1981, ‘The tyranny of principles’, Hastings Center Report 11, 31–39.
Van, J.: October 3, 1982, ‘Medic charges death cop out’, Chicago Tribune 3, 18.
Veatch, R. M.: 1975, ‘The whole-brain oriented concept of death: An outmoded philosophical formulation’, Journal of Thanatology 3, 13–30.
Veatch, R. M.: 1978, ‘The definition of death: Ethical, philosophical and policy confusion’, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 315, 307–321.
Walton, D.: 1981, ‘The epistemology of brain death determination’, Metamedicine 2, 259–274.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Thomasma, D.C. The comatose patient, the ontology of death, and the decision to stop treatment. Theor Med Bioeth 5, 181–196 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00489490
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00489490