Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2014 October 26: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Strange Tales (pulp magazines): Comment |
→Caitlin snow: Reply |
||
Line 13:
Both are redirects to a specific version of a comic book character. The first is essentially redundant as typing in the name using any capitalization version yields the same result. It also does not currently point directly from use in an article, only from and ANI thread and copy of that thread. This redirect is unneeded and should be deleted. The second is only linked to various Ironman competition articles which list "Caitlin Snow" as a competitor. The redirect as it currently stands results in an incorrect linkage of subjects. Given the ambiguity over which Caitlin Snow a reader could be looking for, this redirect should be moved to either [[Caitlin Snow (Comics)]] (preferred dabbing based on the Comics WikiProject) or [[Caitlin Snow (Character)]] (the comic book character has been adapted for use in a television series) and '''Caitlin Snow''' reserved for a possible dab page. This would also imply that the links in the 2009-2014 Ironman World Championship and 2010-2014 Ironman 70.3 World Championship pages (11 in total) be changed to pont to [[Caitlin Snow (Athlete)]]. - [[User:J Greb|J Greb]] ([[User talk:J Greb|talk]]) 14:01, 26 October 2014 (UTC)
*'''Obvious keep''' and disambiguate if necessary. This is what redirects are for. --[[User talk:NE2|NE2]] 14:20, 26 October 2014 (UTC)
** For clarity: I ''am'' suggesting '''Caitlin Snow''' as it currently is get moved. '''Caitlin snow''' is redundant even if moved and should be deleted. Frankly, since the search algorithm here and through places like Google are case insensitive, two essentially identical redirects should never have been created at the same time. - [[User:J Greb|J Greb]] ([[User talk:J Greb|talk]]) 15:19, 26 October 2014 (UTC)
====<span id="Strange Tales (pulp magazines)">Strange Tales (pulp magazines)</span>====
| |||