Colors II

In regards of the conception of the album, vocalist Tommy Giles Rogers Jr. explained:^[3]

Especially with 2020, we really wanted to give it all we could and show the world we’re still here. That’s part of the reason we named it Colors II. We were in a similar spot when we did the first Colors. Back then, we had just gotten done with Ozzfest. We were wondering, 'Where do we belong in this music scene?' We still struggle with that. At both of these moments in our career, we decided to just be ourselves and write the best album we can. We came out guns blazing, and I feel like it’s some of our most creative material in a long time.

Guitarist Paul Waggoner added:

Colors was very much our attempt at a do-or-die statement. We had to establish our identity and be who we really wanted to be in order to have a career. This time around, our industry was shut down for a year. Once tours were canceled due to the pandemic, we were like, 'We've got to write a record, and it's got to be good'. We had to do something next level.

About the concept, Rogers commented:

Musically, it flows like a sequel to Colors, but it wasn’t just another version of that album. On the original, I was analyzing myself and analyzing humanity. With last year, I was in a perfect position to do that. I wrote lyrics in the same way, but they felt new. It was more of a real-world concept by virtue of making a continuation. Music’s purpose is to help. That's a big theme of this album. Once our songs are done, they belong to our listeners. Maybe this will help them move forward creatively or in life.

And about the track "Fix the Error", he shared:

The intention was to write a metal song with a big gospel vibe. It turned into this monster. It's a small story on the record about this guy who lives in a big apocalyptic city. He retires from his job, but he wants to take down this huge corporation. The song is a celebration of taking down corruption and saying, 'Fuck you', to the man. It's about as punk as we’ll ever get.

The first single "Fix the Error" was released on June 25, 2021. An animated music video was released for the song on July 7, 2021, animated by Tony Celano.^[4] The second single "Revolution in Limbo" was released on July 23, 2021.^[5] A music video for "The Future Is Behind Us" was released on August 20, 2021, the same date as the album release.^[6]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	68/100[7]
Review scores
Source	Rating
Blabbermouth.net	8/10[8]
Exclaim!	7/10[9]
Kerrang!	4/5[10]
Metal Hammer	[11]
Metal Injection	9.5/10[12]

The album received generally positive reviews from music critics upon its release. On review aggregator Metacritic, the album holds a score of 68 out of 100 based on four reviews.^[7]

Kerrang! gave the album 4 out of 5 with writer James Hickie stating: "Unsurprisingly, at 80 minutes long, and with exhaustive closing track 'Human Is Hell (Another One with Love)' taking up 15 of those, it's entirely too much music to wrestle with on cursory listens, and requires serious dedication, though that's no bad thing in an age when streaming has fundamentally altered the attention span. As a result, the uninitiated are likely to be overwhelmed by such a glut of material, particularly when it takes so many stylistic detours and about-turns. It's worth the endeavour, though, because there's some sublime music here, deep and diverse, which has plenty to offer nerds and newbies alike."^[10]

Metal Hammer gave the album a positive review, stating: "In being so loyal to the structure of what's come before, Colors II doesn't reinvent progressive metal like its predecessor, but by all other metrics, it lives up to its lineage. It's the only album to ever recapture Colors' brand of restlessness, reaffirming that BTBAM are once-in-a-lifetime masterminds."^[11]

Credits for Colors II adapted from liner notes.^[20]

Between the Buried and Me

• Tommy Giles Rogers Jr. – vocals, keyboards
• Paul Waggoner – lead guitar
• Dustie Waring – rhythm guitar
• Dan Briggs – bass, keyboards
• Blake Richardson – drums, harsh vocals on "Revolution in Limbo"

Additional musicians

• Mike Portnoy – first drum solo on "Fix the Error"
• Navene Koperweis – second drum solo on "Fix the Error"
• Ken Schalk – third drum solo on "Fix the Error"

Production

• Jamie King – production, engineering
• Jens Bogren – mixing
• Richardo Borges – mixing
• Tony Lindgren – mastering
• Corey Meyers – photography, layout, design
• Jason Prushko – engineering
• Thomas Cuce – engineering
• Aaron Strelecki – photography